- permanent portfolio w/ active component
- rebalances monthly
- invests in
- U.S. equities
- U.S. Treasuries
Wouter J. Keller is a researcher at the VU University Amsterdam and the CEO of Flex Capital, an asset management firm based in the Netherlands. Keller published the Lethargic Asset Allocation (LAA) strategy in a paper released in December 2019.
The central concept of the Lethargic Asset Allocation is to combine a macro-economic indicator with trend-following to determine when to switch between risk-on and risk-off portfolio allocations.
LAA rebalances once per month. Combined with the simplicity of rebalancing, the Lethargic Asset Allocation has meager maintenance requirements.
The chart above shows the portfolio's historical performance and drawdowns, compared to their benchmark, throughout the simulation. The chart below shows the portfolio's annual returns:
This table shows the performance metrics for Keller's Lethargic Asset Allocation:
The portfolio last required rebalancing after the exchange's close on n/a. Due to fluctuations in asset prices and portfolio values, the exact allocations vary daily. The current asset allocation is as follows:
The operation of Lethargic Asset Allocation can be summarized as follows:
- start with a risk-off asset allocation similar to Harry Browne's Permanent Portfolio
- determine economic cycle based on unemployment numbers
- determine market regime based on trend following
- if unemployment numbers are falling or markets are rising, switch to a risk-on asset allocation
The strategy rules go back to Philosophical Economics' work on combining a macro-economic indicator with trend following. They named their concept Growth-Trend Timing and used it to switch between just two assets: stocks and cash. Philosophical Economics explains the full rationale behind their strategy in a detailed blog post published in 2016. We like their concept a lot, as it reflects the observation that market corrections outside of a recession are mostly short-lived and do not justify an asset rotation.
Keller expanded upon this concept by switching between two asset allocations, and researching which asset allocations work best. He concludes to start with a conservative allocation similar to the Permanent Portfolio and use it as the risk-off allocation. In calm times, Keller replaces cash with more stocks, significantly boosting returns. Keller describes his findings in his detailed paper.
As a passive portfolio, the Permanent Portfolio is highly regarded, combining decent returns with a low-risk profile. Through the addition of well thought out active management, Keller has made substantial improvements to these qualities.
The Lethargic Asset Allocation is included in the TuringTrader.org open-source project. For those interested in diving deeper into the details, we recommend reviewing the C# source code in the repository.
Just like the Permanent Portfolio, the Lethargic Asset Allocation is always well-diversified across multiple asset classes. The combination of asset classes should do well in almost all economic environments. Keller backtested the strategy from February 1949 to October 2019, showing how the strategy performed evenly across many different economic and market regimes.
Returns & Volatility
In the long term, Keller's Lethargic Asset Allocation provides returns that are only slightly higher than those of a static 60/40 allocation. However, LAA achieves this return with significantly lower volatility. Therefore, LAA's risk-adjusted returns, as indicated by the Ulcer Performance Index, are more than twice as high.
Because most of the time LAA allocates only 25% to bonds, the strategy bears much less interest-rate risk than many other low-volatility portfolios. Also, the higher stock allocation helps the returns.
In historical backtesting, the strategy has shown docile behavior and low drawdowns. However, investors should note that in its risk-on configuration, LAA allocates 50% of the capital toward U.S. stocks. Therefore, LAA may bear risks similar to a passive 50/50 allocation, when market environments shift faster than the strategy's inherent 1-month lag allows.
Account & Tax Considerations
Keller’s LAA strategy triggers taxable events when switching between its risk-on and risk-off allocations. However, because switching occurs so rarely, and because 75% of the assets are held throughout, LAA is very tax efficient.
The Lethargic Asset Allocation invests in 4 ETFs simultaneously. To do so, it requires a minimum capital of about $4,000 to function as intended.